Meanwhile, Elsewhere...

Another week, another batch of renewable announcements from countries that aren't dealing with Pennsylvania permitting lawyers.

Meanwhile, Elsewhere...

While American energy executives spent this week navigating yet another round of interconnection queue delays and wondering if their latest pipeline will survive the next election cycle, the rest of the world kept busy cutting ribbons on actual projects.

Take South Africa's De Aar wind complex, where Chinese developers just flipped the switch on what they're calling a "luxury-to-reality" transformation for local electricity supply. The project is part of a broader 25-year China-Africa partnership that's delivered more gigawatts than most U.S. utilities have managed to interconnect in the same timeframe. The irony isn't lost on anyone who's tried to build anything larger than a gas peaker plant in ERCOT lately.

Meanwhile, the UK and Philippines announced yet another "climate partnership" focused on offshore wind development and marine planning. The Brits, having successfully navigated their own offshore wind procurement disasters, are now exporting that expertise to Southeast Asia. The Philippines gets technical assistance; UK companies get market access. Everyone wins, except perhaps the LNG terminal developers who were counting on Manila's baseload needs.

These announcements arrive as American energy developers continue their slow-motion dance with regulatory uncertainty. The latest Federal Energy Regulatory Commission queue reports show another quarter of projects withdrawn, delayed, or stuck in study limbo. Solar developers in particular are discovering that "shovel-ready" means something different when you're dealing with transmission operators who've been burned by interconnection cost overruns.

The Math Problem

The numbers tell a familiar story. While overseas projects move from announcement to commercial operation in 3-4 years, American renewable developers are learning to think in presidential terms. That offshore wind lease you bid on in 2021? Maybe it'll be generating electrons by 2030, assuming the supply chain cooperates and nobody files another lawsuit.

Chinese wind turbine manufacturers, unburdened by Jones Act restrictions and domestic content requirements, continue to drive down global installation costs. Their latest generation turbines are hitting capacity factors that would make a Permian Basin operator jealous, assuming anyone still cares about capacity factors when the real constraint is getting power to where people actually need it.

Australian economic data, buried in the week's energy news, offers another data point. Household spending patterns show consumers prioritizing essentials over discretionary purchases – a trend that typically correlates with higher energy costs. The Reserve Bank of Australia kept rates steady, but the underlying message remains: energy transitions cost money, and somebody has to pay for them.

The American Exception

Back home, utility-scale battery storage installations continue exceeding projections, though mostly in states that figured out permitting before the rest of the country discovered grid-scale storage was a real business. Texas leads deployment, because of course it does. When you've got ERCOT's market design and minimal regulatory friction, good things happen quickly.

The latest Energy Information Administration data shows another month of coal plant retirements, with operators citing economics rather than regulations. When your fuel costs more than the market-clearing price for 16 hours a day, the math becomes straightforward. Natural gas peaker plants are discovering similar arithmetic as battery storage costs continue their downward trajectory.

Pipeline developers, meanwhile, are learning new vocabulary. "Regulatory uncertainty" used to mean permitting delays. Now it encompasses everything from eminent domain challenges to stranded asset risks as industrial customers explore electrification alternatives. The latest Marcellus shale production forecasts assume takeaway capacity that may or may not exist, depending on which federal judge reviews the next environmental impact statement.

Reality Check

None of this changes the fundamental physics of American electricity markets. Someone still needs to keep the lights on when the wind doesn't blow and the sun doesn't shine. Natural gas generators provide that service today, and probably will for the next decade, regardless of what gets announced at international climate conferences.

But the competitive landscape keeps shifting. Every overseas renewable project that comes online ahead of schedule and under budget makes American energy infrastructure look increasingly expensive by comparison. Every Chinese wind turbine exported to Africa or Southeast Asia is one less potential sale for American manufacturers still figuring out how to compete without subsidies.

The South African wind project will probably generate electricity for 25 years, long enough to outlast several American political cycles. By then, today's energy transition will be ancient history, and whatever comes next will make current debates about renewable portfolio standards seem quaint.

For now, American energy professionals get to watch other countries execute what used to be American expertise: building large-scale infrastructure projects on time and on budget. The rest of the world didn't get the memo about permitting delays being inevitable.

Subscribe to Charcoal News

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe